[交流] 大家來記憶卡賽豬公嘍~ (PDA 記憶卡測試募集)

Milton

記憶卡：PHOTOFAST Super SD 1GB 150倍
測試機器：Palm Treo 650

VFSMark Results
(測三次取平均值)
File Create:        307% ;
File Delete:        491% ;
File Write:        126% ;
File Read:        669% ;
File Seek:        737% ;
DB Export:        395% ;
DB Import:        420% ;
Record Access:        733% ;
Resource Access:        669% ;

VFSMark:        505 ;  

以價格來說, 還好~~

阿輝

今天花了點時間整理 (應該弄個線上資料庫還簡單些 =_=)

檔案整理於第一篇，內含 73 個取樣資料
Excel 阿輝不是很擅長，表格非常陽春很抱歉

isamuplus

因為現在PDA跟像機是共用一張256MB的記憶卡，趁著今天到了台中Nova，就想敗一
張新卡，特地挑了一家目前沒有人測的廠牌〔威剛〕...

A-Data SD 512MB 150X 超人特攻隊版 @ Palm Tungsten T3

VFSMark Results

File Create:    692%
File Delete:    883%
File Write:    318%
File Read:    748%
File Seek:    1180%
DB Export:    460%
DB Import:    1074%
Record Access:    928%
Resource Access:    872%

VFSMark:    795

然後突然想到我家另外一台像機還有一張卡可以測。

Apacer SD 256MB 60X @ Palm Tungsten T3

VFSMark Results

File Create:    245%
File Delete:    145%
File Write:    60%
File Read:    725%
File Seek:    983%
DB Export:    141%
DB Import:    857%
Record Access:    841%
Resource Access:    768%

VFSMark:    529

因為沒有Sony的機種，不然其實手上還有一張512MB的MS Pro...XD

nathan

測試記憶卡：SanDisk Ultra II 1.0GB
測試機器：Palm Treo 650

VFS 測試資料：
VFSMark Results

File Create:    586%
File Delete:    313%
File Write:    58%
File Read:    662%
File Seek:    786%
DB Export:    48%
DB Import:    405%
Record Access:    696%
Resource Access:    640%

VFSMark:    466

小螞蟻

測試記憶卡：MAXGOLD 170X 2G SD
測試機器：Palm Treo 650

VFS 測試資料：

VFSMark Results

File Create:    154%
File Delete:    57%
File Write:    25%
File Read:    692%
File Seek:    983%
DB Export:    117%
DB Import:    337%
Record Access:    861%
Resource Access:    800%

VFSMark:    447

HHSL

有些小小的疑問，

除了write、read和mark的數值，一張高速的sd卡，是否應該將省電列入考慮呢？
還有，同廠牌不同時期同規格的卡，會不會有差呢？

阿輝

除了write、read和mark的數值，一張高速的sd卡，是否應該將省電列入考慮呢？

這點到不用擔心，因為這麼多年來，大概也沒聽說什麼耗電很嚴重的記憶卡
除非記憶卡故障

還有，同廠牌不同時期同規格的卡，會不會有差呢？

有可能，所以需要盡量多的取樣

isamuplus

特別耗電的除了MicroDrive以外，其他用NAND的Flash產品都只是半斤八兩
吧，反正"寫入的資料"就那麼多，耗電量充其量也就那麼多罷了...

小酒蟲

Originally posted by samuel168 at 2005-11-7 17:08:
為什麼沒有人用4GB的卡來測?

有點何不食肉糜的錯覺....畢竟 4GB SD 仍算是高價品，不如你買張來交流交流吧。8D

ccfan

Originally posted by samuel168 at 2005-11-8 09:08:
看完整串下來, 小弟有個疑問

為什麼沒有人用4GB的卡來測?

是Palm會讀不到? 還是讀卡機會讀不到?

mytreo的討論區有人提過,Treo 650只抓的到2GB的SD卡.
還是想買的話,不如舊帶著機子去測試看看,可以再買.

TeddyJu

測試機器：T|X
記憶卡：PhotoFast 1G SD卡(PxHxme館長推薦那一張Super 150x SD 1G)

VFSMark Results
File Create:    460%
File Delete:    561%
File Write:    15%
File Read:    539%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    218%
DB Import:    212%
Record Access:    1005%
Resource Access:    1037%

VFSMark:    886

====================================
File Write 夭壽慢....
全新卡,全新機器測試

[ Last edited by TeddyJu on 2005-11-16 at 21:02 ]

57th

測試機器：T|X
記憶卡：RiDATA 2G SD 150X

測了幾次後，出現兩種結果

A.

VFSMark Results
File Create:    507%
File Delete:    1096%
File Write:    250%
File Read:    545%
File Seek:    5900%
DB Export:    504%
DB Import:    305%
Record Access:    1206%
Resource Access:    1280%

VFSMark:    1288


B.

VFSMark Results
File Create:    504%
File Delete:    1014%
File Write:    257%
File Read:    545%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    493%
DB Import:    302%
Record Access:    1248%
Resource Access:    1324%

VFSMark:    1068

看起來我的SD卡會暴走|)

TeddyJu

測試機器：T|X
記憶卡：RiDATA 1GB PRO 66X

VFSMark Results
File Create:    253%
File Delete:    114%
File Write:    73%
File Read:    521%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    141%
DB Import:    192%
Record Access:    978%
Resource Access:    1010%

VFSMark:    801

czh

Palm對FAT32的支援似乎很差
可是用FAT大於2G他又認不到Orz

Palm TX + Transcend 4G SD 150X
File Create:    202%
File Delete:    51%
File Write:    123%
File Read:    509%
File Seek:    1966%
DB Export:    87%
DB Import:    303%
Record Access:    1167%
Resource Access:    1129%
VFSMark:    615

Palm TX + Transcend 4G SD 150X + FAT32.patched.prc
File Create:    201%
File Delete:    51%
File Write:    122%
File Read:    509%
File Seek:    2360%
DB Export:    87%
DB Import:    300%
Record Access:    1206%
Resource Access:    1129%
VFSMark:    662

Palm TX + Lexar 1G SD
File Create:    335%
File Delete:    340%
File Write:    63%
File Read:    527%
File Seek:    2360%
DB Export:    209%
DB Import:    274%
Record Access:    1096%
Resource Access:    1163%
VFSMark:    707

czh

重新格式化過竟然產生這麼大的差異
新紀錄誕生!!!
看來測之前要格式化過比較准

Palm TX + Transcend 4G SD 150X
File Create:    203%
File Delete:    52%
File Write:    123%
File Read:    527%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    89%
DB Import:    308%
Record Access:    1292%
Resource Access:    1200%
VFSMark:    858

Palm TX + Lexar 1G SD
File Create:    2311%
File Delete:    2344%
File Write:    60%
File Read:    545%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    192%
DB Import:    278%
Record Access:    1292%
Resource Access:    1324%
VFSMark:    1364

seawind

測試記憶卡：廣穎電通(Silicon Power) 133X 1G SD (在Nova抽到用999買的)

測試機器：Treo 650

VFS 測試資料：

VFSMark Results

File Create:    109%
File Delete:    59%
File Write:    26%
File Read:    618%
File Seek:    536%
DB Export:    67%
DB Import:    358%
Record Access:    658%
Resource Access:    590%

VFSMark:    335

卡上內容無del

小酒蟲

Originally posted by czh at 2005-11-27 18:29:
Palm對FAT32的支援似乎很差

Palm TX + Transcend 4G SD 150X + FAT32.patched.prc

Palm T|X 本身不支援 FAT32？我還以為 LifeDrive 之後的機子都吃 FAT32 了。B)

哆啦A夢

記憶卡：威剛 超人特攻隊版 SD 1GB 150倍
測試機器：Palm T3

VFSMark Results

File Create:            768%
File Delete:             931%
File Write:              370%
File Read:               760%
File Seek:              1311%
DB Export:               460%
DB Import:             1045%
Record Access:        928%
Resource Access:     893%

VFSMark:        829

czh

Originally posted by 小酒蟲 at 2005-12-1 01:23 PM:

Palm T|X 本身不支援 FAT32？我還以為 LifeDrive 之後的機子都吃 FAT32 了。B)

是有支援沒錯
我只是試試非官方驅動程式是否有好一點

oversky

記憶卡：Transcend 2G SD 150X
測試機器：Palm TX

VFSMark Results

File Create:        214%
File Delete:        1000%
File Write:        253%
File Read:        545%
File Seek:        3933%
DB Export:        298%
DB Import:        299%
Record Access:        1248%
Resource Access:        1280%

VFSMark:        1007

[ Last edited by oversky on 2005-12-11 at 00:13 ]

ma1121

測試記憶卡：KingMax T-Flash (128MB )
測試機器：X-Pro P368


VFS 測試資料：

1. VFSMark Results
   
2. 
   
3. File Create:    300%
   
4. File Delete:    274%
   
5. File Write:    64%
   
6. File Read:    414%
   
7. File Seek:    561%
   
8. DB Export:    185%
   
9. DB Import:    302%
   
10. Record Access:    683%
    
11. Resource Access:    629%
    
12. 
    
13. VFSMark:    379

複製代碼

========================================================
Palm based 的機器上測T-Flash卡應該不常見吧...噗...

stick28

威剛 超人特攻隊版的SD write都好強喔。
因為是超人的原因嗎？  Orz

哆啦A夢

Originally posted by stick28 at 2005-12-14 11:16 PM:
威剛 超人特攻隊版的SD write都好強喔。
因為是超人的原因嗎？  Orz

沒錯!
而且還送5片sd card

大小的磁鐵耶!

adamchang

TX+仿冒的ridata 1G SD卡(詳情請看友站的相同經驗,http://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=61&t=120982),我也睬到地雷了


File Create:760%
File Delete:647%
File Write :196%
File Read :539%
File Seek :3933%
DB Export :187%
DB Import :265%
Record Access : 1131%
Resource Access:1238%

VFSMark:988