[交流] 大家來記憶卡賽豬公嘍~ (PDA 記憶卡測試募集)

isamuplus

特別耗電的除了MicroDrive以外，其他用NAND的Flash產品都只是半斤八兩
吧，反正"寫入的資料"就那麼多，耗電量充其量也就那麼多罷了...

小酒蟲

Originally posted by samuel168 at 2005-11-7 17:08:
為什麼沒有人用4GB的卡來測?

有點何不食肉糜的錯覺....畢竟 4GB SD 仍算是高價品，不如你買張來交流交流吧。8D

ccfan

Originally posted by samuel168 at 2005-11-8 09:08:
看完整串下來, 小弟有個疑問

為什麼沒有人用4GB的卡來測?

是Palm會讀不到? 還是讀卡機會讀不到?

mytreo的討論區有人提過,Treo 650只抓的到2GB的SD卡.
還是想買的話,不如舊帶著機子去測試看看,可以再買.

TeddyJu

測試機器：T|X
記憶卡：PhotoFast 1G SD卡(PxHxme館長推薦那一張Super 150x SD 1G)

VFSMark Results
File Create:    460%
File Delete:    561%
File Write:    15%
File Read:    539%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    218%
DB Import:    212%
Record Access:    1005%
Resource Access:    1037%

VFSMark:    886

====================================
File Write 夭壽慢....
全新卡,全新機器測試

[ Last edited by TeddyJu on 2005-11-16 at 21:02 ]

57th

測試機器：T|X
記憶卡：RiDATA 2G SD 150X

測了幾次後，出現兩種結果

A.

VFSMark Results
File Create:    507%
File Delete:    1096%
File Write:    250%
File Read:    545%
File Seek:    5900%
DB Export:    504%
DB Import:    305%
Record Access:    1206%
Resource Access:    1280%

VFSMark:    1288


B.

VFSMark Results
File Create:    504%
File Delete:    1014%
File Write:    257%
File Read:    545%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    493%
DB Import:    302%
Record Access:    1248%
Resource Access:    1324%

VFSMark:    1068

看起來我的SD卡會暴走|)

TeddyJu

測試機器：T|X
記憶卡：RiDATA 1GB PRO 66X

VFSMark Results
File Create:    253%
File Delete:    114%
File Write:    73%
File Read:    521%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    141%
DB Import:    192%
Record Access:    978%
Resource Access:    1010%

VFSMark:    801

czh

Palm對FAT32的支援似乎很差
可是用FAT大於2G他又認不到Orz

Palm TX + Transcend 4G SD 150X
File Create:    202%
File Delete:    51%
File Write:    123%
File Read:    509%
File Seek:    1966%
DB Export:    87%
DB Import:    303%
Record Access:    1167%
Resource Access:    1129%
VFSMark:    615

Palm TX + Transcend 4G SD 150X + FAT32.patched.prc
File Create:    201%
File Delete:    51%
File Write:    122%
File Read:    509%
File Seek:    2360%
DB Export:    87%
DB Import:    300%
Record Access:    1206%
Resource Access:    1129%
VFSMark:    662

Palm TX + Lexar 1G SD
File Create:    335%
File Delete:    340%
File Write:    63%
File Read:    527%
File Seek:    2360%
DB Export:    209%
DB Import:    274%
Record Access:    1096%
Resource Access:    1163%
VFSMark:    707

czh

重新格式化過竟然產生這麼大的差異
新紀錄誕生!!!
看來測之前要格式化過比較准

Palm TX + Transcend 4G SD 150X
File Create:    203%
File Delete:    52%
File Write:    123%
File Read:    527%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    89%
DB Import:    308%
Record Access:    1292%
Resource Access:    1200%
VFSMark:    858

Palm TX + Lexar 1G SD
File Create:    2311%
File Delete:    2344%
File Write:    60%
File Read:    545%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    192%
DB Import:    278%
Record Access:    1292%
Resource Access:    1324%
VFSMark:    1364

seawind

測試記憶卡：廣穎電通(Silicon Power) 133X 1G SD (在Nova抽到用999買的)

測試機器：Treo 650

VFS 測試資料：

VFSMark Results

File Create:    109%
File Delete:    59%
File Write:    26%
File Read:    618%
File Seek:    536%
DB Export:    67%
DB Import:    358%
Record Access:    658%
Resource Access:    590%

VFSMark:    335

卡上內容無del

小酒蟲

Originally posted by czh at 2005-11-27 18:29:
Palm對FAT32的支援似乎很差

Palm TX + Transcend 4G SD 150X + FAT32.patched.prc

Palm T|X 本身不支援 FAT32？我還以為 LifeDrive 之後的機子都吃 FAT32 了。B)

哆啦A夢

記憶卡：威剛 超人特攻隊版 SD 1GB 150倍
測試機器：Palm T3

VFSMark Results

File Create:            768%
File Delete:             931%
File Write:              370%
File Read:               760%
File Seek:              1311%
DB Export:               460%
DB Import:             1045%
Record Access:        928%
Resource Access:     893%

VFSMark:        829

czh

Originally posted by 小酒蟲 at 2005-12-1 01:23 PM:

Palm T|X 本身不支援 FAT32？我還以為 LifeDrive 之後的機子都吃 FAT32 了。B)

是有支援沒錯
我只是試試非官方驅動程式是否有好一點

oversky

記憶卡：Transcend 2G SD 150X
測試機器：Palm TX

VFSMark Results

File Create:        214%
File Delete:        1000%
File Write:        253%
File Read:        545%
File Seek:        3933%
DB Export:        298%
DB Import:        299%
Record Access:        1248%
Resource Access:        1280%

VFSMark:        1007

[ Last edited by oversky on 2005-12-11 at 00:13 ]

ma1121

測試記憶卡：KingMax T-Flash (128MB )
測試機器：X-Pro P368


VFS 測試資料：

1. VFSMark Results
   
2. 
   
3. File Create:    300%
   
4. File Delete:    274%
   
5. File Write:    64%
   
6. File Read:    414%
   
7. File Seek:    561%
   
8. DB Export:    185%
   
9. DB Import:    302%
   
10. Record Access:    683%
    
11. Resource Access:    629%
    
12. 
    
13. VFSMark:    379

複製代碼

========================================================
Palm based 的機器上測T-Flash卡應該不常見吧...噗...

stick28

威剛 超人特攻隊版的SD write都好強喔。
因為是超人的原因嗎？  Orz

哆啦A夢

Originally posted by stick28 at 2005-12-14 11:16 PM:
威剛 超人特攻隊版的SD write都好強喔。
因為是超人的原因嗎？  Orz

沒錯!
而且還送5片sd card

大小的磁鐵耶!

adamchang

TX+仿冒的ridata 1G SD卡(詳情請看友站的相同經驗,http://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=61&t=120982),我也睬到地雷了


File Create:760%
File Delete:647%
File Write :196%
File Read :539%
File Seek :3933%
DB Export :187%
DB Import :265%
Record Access : 1131%
Resource Access:1238%

VFSMark:988

stick28

測試記憶卡：Kingston  SD - 1GB，使用容量Omb。
測試機器：Palm Treo 650



VFS 測試資料：

File Create:    230%
File Delete:    407%
File Write:    14%
File Read:    692%
File Seek:    907%
DB Export:    200%
DB Import:    492%
Record Access:    822%
Resource Access:    768%

VFSMark:    503

呼~~
File Write:    14%，昏倒。


同一張卡，格式化後未使用再測試一次


VFS 測試資料：

File Create:    270%
File Delete:    175%
File Write:    15%
File Read:    682%
File Seek:    842%
DB Export:    220%
DB Import:   476%
Record Access:   804%
Resource Access:    768%

VFSMark:    472

HSIEN

測試記憶卡：Apacer SD1G 150X
測試機器：Palm T|X

以FAT16格式化後                                      
VFSMark Results                                       
File Create:        560%                                   
File Delete:        1014%                                 
File Write:        199%                                    
File Read:        545%                                    
File Seek:        3933%
DB Export:        504%
DB Import:        313%
Record Access:        1248%
Resource Access:        1280%
VFSMark:        1066
------------------------------------------------------------------
而在FAT32格式化後
VFSMark Results
File Create:    225%
File Delete:    77%
File Write:    126%
File Read:    527%
File Seek:    3933%
DB Export:    129%
DB Import:    316%
Record Access:    1292%
Resource Access:    1280%
VFSMark:    878
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
我的擴充卡似乎有問題，格式化成FAT16的情形下，
只要抜出再插回，TX就不認它，非要進行格式化。

但格式化成FAT32的情形下，目前使用正常，沒有上述問題。

iamnobody

測試記憶卡：Apacer 150X 1G
測試機器：Palm Treo 650

VFSMark Results

File Create:        413%
File Delete:        581%
File Write:        195%
File Read:        703%
File Seek:        907%
DB Export:        605%
DB Import:        412%
Record Access:        822%
Resource Access:        768%

VFSMark:        600

阿宗

記憶卡：威剛 超人特攻隊版 SD 1GB 150倍
測試機器：Treo 650

VFSMark Results
File Create:            862%
File Delete:            944%
File Write:             429%
File Read:             682%
File Seek:              842%
DB Export:            848%
DB Import:            468%
Record Access:       804%
Resource Access:    738%

VFSMark:        735

patkinpa

測試記憶卡：Kingston Elite pro SD - 512MB(日本製)
測試機器：Palm T3

VFSMark Results
File Create:    416%
File Delete:    260%
File Write:    146%
File Read:    559%
File Seek:    536%
DB Export:    265%
DB Import:    465%
Record Access:    540%
Resource Access:    474%
VFSMark:    406

stick28

測試記憶卡：超人1GB SD卡，使用容量Omb。
測試機器：Palm Treo 650



VFS 測試資料：

File Create:    354%
File Delete:    531%
File Write:    14%
File Read:    692%
File Seek:    907%
DB Export:    298%
DB Import:    529%
Record Access:    786%
Resource Access:    768%

VFSMark:    542

用570元+大集大利點數換來的1g card，
用toshiba的晶片，一看到這個晶片，就知道寫入一定比較差，
果然…才14。

triffy

Originally posted by David_Ch at 2006-3-19 09:27 PM:
順便補上 Treo-650 附送的 PalmOne 256MB MMC 卡剛 Format 完的數據:

File Create:        565%
File Delete:        478%
File Write:        65%
File Read:        317%
File Seek:        737%
DB Export:        198%
DB Import:        405%
Record Access:        565%
Resource Access:        533%
VFSMark:        429

手上這一張創見真的應該去撞牆... Orz...

別小看這一張
這張可是改版過的MMC啊. XD

理論上是原本MMC卡的四倍速度...
當初Liaolc就說過，Palm給的禮物可還真是給足了面子
如果容量再大一點就好了...

ydtseng

測試機：TREO 650
FW:1.13

===================================

Toshiba 2G

File Create:    306%
File Delete:    192%
File Write:    14%
File Read:    644%
File Seek:    655%
DB Export:    230%
DB Import:    383%
Record Access:    683%
Resource Access:    640%

VFSMark:    416

===================================

SanDisk 1G

File Create:    702%
File Delete:    369%
File Write:    209%
File Read:    644%
File Seek:    561%
DB Export:    392%
DB Import:    365%
Record Access:    646%
Resource Access:    640%

VFSMark:    503
===================================

PhotoFast <Speed Ultra> 1G

File Create:    319%
File Delete:    278%
File Write:    34%
File Read:    662%
File Seek:    694%
DB Export:    359%
DB Import:    374%
Record Access:    709%
Resource Access:    650%

VFSMark:    453

===================================

Lexar 1G

File Create:    273%
File Delete:    243%
File Write:    57%
File Read:    653%
File Seek:    590%
DB Export:    185%
DB Import:    336%
Record Access:    738%
Resource Access:    685%

VFSMark:    417

===================================

Impress 512M

File Create:    238%
File Delete:    136%
File Write:    59%
File Read:    627%
File Seek:    561%
DB Export:    152%
DB Import:    283%
Record Access:    624%
Resource Access:    564%

VFSMark:    360

===================================

SanDisk 512M T-FlASH

File Create:    83%
File Delete:    49%
File Write:    71%
File Read:    618%
File Seek:    513%
DB Export:    55%
DB Import:    321%
Record Access:    603%
Resource Access:    564%

VFSMark:    319

===================================

Jonry

再來測測最近入手的兩張 SD 卡吧...

測試機: Treo 650, FW: 1.21

SanDisk Extreme III 1GB:

File Create:    378%
File Delete:    189%
File Write:    208%
File Read:    682%
File Seek:    786%
DB Export:    218%
DB Import:    408%
Record Access:    822%
Resource Access:    783%

VFSMark:    497

======================================

Kingston Ultimate 2GB

File Create:    742%
File Delete:    918%
File Write:    495%
File Read:    692%
File Seek:    842%
DB Export:    883%
DB Import:    405%
Record Access:    841%
Resource Access:    783%

VFSMark:    733


不過我個人覺得, Treo650 的記憶卡控制晶片也許沒有多好
起碼我在 PC 上測試的數據, Extreme III 應該比 Ultimate 快一點...

小螞蟻

Treo 650 fw1.20 記憶卡格式：fat16

威剛2G SD
VFSMark Results

File Create:390%
File Delete:323%
File Write:53%
File Read:682%
File Seek:907%
DB Export:302%
DB Import:        485%
Record Access:786%
Resource Access:738%

VFSMark:        518

[ Last edited by 小螞蟻 on 2006-3-22 at 15:27 ]

bongarcon

測試平台：Treo650 1.20/1.72 精簡版+FAT32（無 Versamail, RealPlayer... 等, DBCache 12779248）
兩張卡（Kingston 512MB 及 APD 1GB）測試，分別在 PC 做兩種格式化 FAT16/FAT32。
結果如下，顯然FAT16 比較好一些。
FileWrite 很差，其它都不錯。但不同時間測試結果不太一致。

Kingston FAT16 512KB VFSMark Results

File Create:        344%
File Delete:        1478%
File Write:                350%
File Read:                703%
File Seek:                2950%
DB Export:        543%
DB Import:        485%
Record Access:        1096%
Resource Access:        1066%
VFSMark:                1001



Kingston FAT16 512KB VFSMark Results

File Create:        216%
File Delete:        81%
File Write:                208%
File Read:                662%
File Seek:                2950%
DB Export:        125%
DB Import:        468%
Record Access:        1064%
Resource Access:        1037%
VFSMark:        756



APD FAT16 1G VFSMark Results

File Create:        368%
File Delete:        618%
File Write:                8%
File Read:                703%
File Seek:                2360%
DB Export:        298%
DB Import:        495%
Record Access:        1064%
Resource Access:        1066%
VFSMark:        775

Kingston FAT32 512KB VFSMark Results

File Create:        365%
File Delete:        125%
File Write:                245%
File Read:                662%
File Seek:                2360%
DB Export:        207%
DB Import:        456%
Record Access:        1131%
Resource Access:        1037%
VFSMark:        732

APD FAT32 1G SD VFSMark Results

File Create:        69%
File Delete:        20%
File Write:                12%
File Read:                672%
File Seek:                2360%
DB Export:        29%
DB Import:        512%
Record Access:        1096%
Resource Access:        1037%
VFSMark:        645

APD FAT32 1G SD VFSMark Results

File Create:        70%
File Delete:        20%
File Write:                12%
File Read:                672%
File Seek:                2950%
DB Export:        30%
DB Import:        498%
Record Access:        1096%
Resource Access:        1037%
VFSMark:        709

ccfan

Treo 650
FW: 1.17/1.20 + fat32 patch

APACER 150X 1G SD

File Create:    211%
File Delete:    75%
File Write:    129%
File Read:    692%
File Seek:    2950%
DB Export:    135%
DB Import:    495%
Record Access:    1206%
Resource Access:    1129%

VFSMark:    780

[ Last edited by ccfan on 2006-3-22 at 18:07 ]

yenyo

測試記憶卡：SONY MS PRO DUO 2GB High Speed 版短卡+轉接器
測試機器：SONY TH55 英文版 (CPU 123 MHz)

VFS 測試資料：
VFSMark Results

File Create:    210%
File Delete:    155%
File Write:    365%
File Read:    521%
File Seek:    437%
DB Export:    255%
DB Import:    501%
Record Access:    696%
Resource Access:    498%

VFSMark:    404

好像還是輸SD卡一大截，
Orz......
不過分數有比一般的MS Pro黑卡高一點點!!
主要差別在DB Import、Record Access、Resource Access這三項，
其他項目和MS Pro黑卡數據比較起來其實都差不多!!!

[ Last edited by yenyo on 2006-3-25 at 04:09 ]